The Smarter Mortgage Series | Mortgage Money Myths

“Doug, I have a 3% fixed mortgage. Why did my payment go up $250 a month?”

Imagine purchasing your dream home, locking in a great interest rate, and getting comfortable with your monthly mortgage payment.

Then one day, you open a letter from your mortgage company.

Your payment is going up.

Wait a minute!

You have a fixed-rate mortgage. Isn’t that supposed to mean your payment stays the same?

Well, yes and no.

Your mortgage interest rate can stay exactly the same while your total monthly payment increases.

And depending on the circumstances, that increase could be temporary, permanent, or a combination of both.

Let’s discuss why this happens, how escrow accounts work, and what homeowners can do to avoid unexpected surprises.

What Does a Fixed-Rate Mortgage Actually Mean?

When you obtain a traditional fixed-rate mortgage, your interest rate stays the same throughout the loan term.

On a standard, fully amortizing fixed-rate mortgage, your scheduled principal and interest payment stays the same too.

But there’s something many homeowners overlook.

Your monthly mortgage payment may include more than principal and interest.

In the mortgage industry, we often use the term PITI:

  • Principal: The portion of your payment that reduces your mortgage balance.
  • Interest: The cost of borrowing money.
  • Taxes: Property taxes assessed by local taxing authorities.
  • Insurance: Homeowners insurance protecting your property against covered losses.

Depending on your mortgage, you may also have mortgage insurance. And if you live in a community with a homeowners association, your HOA dues are another housing expense, although they’re generally paid separately.

Here’s the important distinction.

Your principal and interest may be fixed. Your property taxes and insurance aren’t.

And that’s where escrow comes into play.

What Is an Escrow Account?

An escrow account is an account managed by your mortgage servicer to collect funds for certain property-related expenses, usually homeowners insurance and property taxes.

Instead of paying those bills yourself when they’re due, you contribute toward them each month as part of your mortgage payment.

Your servicer then pays the bills from the account.

Sounds simple enough.

But there’s a catch.

Your mortgage servicer must estimate what those expenses will be.

If property taxes increase, insurance premiums rise, or the account doesn’t have enough money to cover projected expenses, your monthly payment may need to change.

That’s when homeowners receive something called an escrow analysis.

And sometimes, the results aren’t what they expected.

How Does a $2,000 Mortgage Payment Become $2,250?

Let’s use a hypothetical example.

You purchased your home with a 3% fixed interest rate.

Your total monthly mortgage payment is $2,000.

Everything is going great until your annual escrow analysis arrives.

Here’s what changed:

Payment ComponentBeforeAfter
Principal and interest$1,650$1,650
Property taxes and insurance$350$450
Escrow shortage repayment$0$150
Total monthly payment$2,000$2,250

Your principal and interest haven’t changed.

Your interest rate is still 3%.

But your projected taxes and insurance increased by $100 per month.

Your servicer also identified a $1,800 escrow shortage, which in this example is being collected over 12 months.

That’s another $150 per month.

Suddenly, your payment has increased by $250.

But here’s something important.

Not all of that increase is necessarily permanent.

Once the $1,800 shortage has been repaid, the additional $150 monthly collection may end, assuming no new shortages or other adjustments.

However, the $100 increase for property taxes and insurance may remain.

Understanding that difference can save homeowners a lot of unnecessary frustration.

What Is an Escrow Shortage?

An escrow shortage occurs when your escrow account contains less money than the amount required under your mortgage servicer’s escrow analysis.

That can happen for several reasons.

Perhaps your property taxes increased.

Maybe your homeowners insurance premium jumped from $1,500 to $2,100.

Or perhaps the original escrow estimates were lower than the actual bills.

Your servicer may also maintain a permitted escrow cushion to account for fluctuations.

If the account doesn’t have sufficient funds, your servicer may need to collect additional money.

Depending on the shortage amount and applicable servicing requirements, you may repay the shortage through an adjustment to your monthly payment.

Your servicer may also accept a voluntary lump-sum payment in certain circumstances.

But here’s something I want homeowners to remember.

Paying an escrow shortage addresses a past shortfall. It doesn’t eliminate higher future expenses.

If your taxes or insurance increased, those higher costs still need to be funded.

I Changed Insurance Companies. Why Did My Escrow Account Come Up Short?

This is one of those situations I wish more homeowners understood.

I had a client who changed homeowners insurance companies approximately nine or ten months into their mortgage.

Their previous insurance company sent them a refund check for the unused portion of their policy.

Sounds like good news, right?

Who doesn’t enjoy getting an unexpected check in the mail?

But here’s where things can get complicated.

A refund from your insurance company is not necessarily a refund from your mortgage escrow account.

When you cancel a prepaid homeowners insurance policy, the insurance company may refund the unused premium directly to you.

Meanwhile, your new insurance company needs to be paid.

If your mortgage servicer pays the replacement policy from your escrow account, that payment may occur before enough funds have accumulated to cover the additional expense.

And if you’ve already spent the refund from your previous insurance company, you may not have that money available to help replenish the account.

In my client’s situation, the refund initially seemed like extra money.

But the timing of the insurance change and escrow payments left the account short when the next insurance payment needed to be accounted for.

The result?

An unexpected escrow adjustment.

My Advice When Changing Homeowners Insurance

If you receive a refund check from your previous insurance company, don’t immediately assume it’s money you can spend.

Before depositing it into your vacation fund, consider these four questions:

  1. Has my mortgage servicer received the new insurance policy?
  2. Was the replacement premium paid from escrow, or did I pay it directly?
  3. When is the next insurance premium due?
  4. Does my escrow account have enough money to cover the upcoming expense?

Sometimes that insurance refund is money you’ll want to set aside or use to replenish escrow.

Switching insurance companies can absolutely be a smart financial decision.

Just make sure you understand how the change affects your escrow account.

An insurance refund and an escrow surplus are two very different things.

Can My Mortgage Payment Actually Go Down?

Absolutely!

We often discuss why mortgage payments increase, but the opposite can happen too.

Maybe your property taxes decrease.

Perhaps you find a more affordable homeowners insurance policy.

Or maybe your annual escrow analysis identifies a surplus.

Depending on the circumstances, your servicer may adjust your monthly escrow payment downward.

And under applicable servicing rules, some escrow surpluses must be refunded to eligible borrowers.

However, receiving a refund doesn’t automatically mean your future monthly payment will decrease.

Your servicer still needs to estimate the funds required for upcoming expenses.

That’s why it’s important to review your escrow analysis rather than simply looking at the amount of the refund.

Arizona Homeowners: Why Are My Property Taxes Increasing?

Here in Arizona, property taxes can change for several reasons.

Your property’s assessed value may change.

Tax rates or levies may change.

New construction or improvements may affect the property’s taxable value.

Or your eligibility for a particular exemption may change.

Arizona uses a property valuation system that isn’t necessarily the same as your home’s current market value or purchase price.

That distinction becomes especially important when purchasing a newly constructed home.

Buying New Construction? Watch Those Initial Property Tax Estimates!

This is one of the most important conversations I have with buyers purchasing new construction.

Imagine buying a beautiful new home.

The builder presents an attractive monthly mortgage payment.

The interest rate looks good.

The payment fits your budget.

Everything seems perfect.

But what if the estimated property taxes don’t fully reflect the completed home?

In some cases, the available tax history may reflect a vacant lot or a property before the completed improvements were incorporated into the county’s assessment records.

That can make the initial tax amount appear unusually low.

Once the completed home is reflected in the county’s valuation process, the taxable value and property taxes may change.

Depending on the county’s assessment calendar, there can be a delay between completion and when those changes appear in the tax bill.

And here’s the risk.

A low initial tax estimate can make a mortgage payment look more affordable than it may be in the future.

Let’s Look at an Example

Suppose your initial mortgage payment includes an estimated $100 per month for property taxes.

Later, after the completed home is reflected in the assessment records, the annual tax amount works out to $300 per month.

That’s an additional $200 per month.

And if your servicer discovers an escrow shortage because the earlier collections were insufficient, you could temporarily pay even more while the shortage is being repaid.

The example is hypothetical, but the financial risk is real.

Now, some buyers may wonder whether they can use a lower initial tax estimate to reduce their mortgage payment during the first year or two.

Any estimate used for mortgage qualification and disclosures must comply with the applicable loan program, lender requirements, and available property tax information.

But even when an initially lower escrow collection is appropriate, it doesn’t necessarily reflect the property’s long-term expenses.

My recommendation is to ask your lender to show you a realistic estimate of what the property taxes could look like once the home is fully assessed.

I’d much rather have a buyer prepared for a future payment increase than surprised by one.

Your home should fit your budget beyond the first year.

Arizona Veterans: Could You Qualify for Property Tax Relief?

As a retired United States Air Force veteran, this topic is particularly important to me.

Arizona provides property tax exemptions for certain qualifying veterans with disabilities.

Under the applicable Arizona exemption provisions, an eligible veteran with a 100% service-connected VA disability rating may qualify for a full property tax exemption on their primary residence, subject to the law’s eligibility requirements.

Other qualifying veterans may be eligible for partial exemptions.

There are application procedures, deadlines, and eligibility conditions that homeowners must meet.

And it’s important to understand that having a particular disability rating doesn’t automatically mean your mortgage servicer will stop collecting property taxes.

The exemption must be approved and reflected in the applicable tax records.

How Could a Property Tax Exemption Affect My Mortgage Payment?

Let’s say your mortgage payment currently includes $250 per month for property taxes.

If you qualify for an exemption that reduces or eliminates those taxes, your escrow requirements may eventually decrease.

But your mortgage payment might not change immediately.

Your mortgage servicer may still be collecting based on the previous tax amount.

Once your exemption is approved, contact your servicer and ask whether an updated escrow analysis can be completed.

You may need to provide the exemption approval or updated property tax documentation.

And remember, a property tax exemption doesn’t eliminate your homeowners insurance or other housing expenses.

How Do I Request a Property Tax Exemption Application in Maricopa County?

Maricopa County provides an online request form that homeowners can use to obtain information or application materials for certain property tax exemptions.

The form isn’t limited to veterans. Other qualifying homeowners may also be eligible for property tax relief depending on their circumstances.

Request Property Tax Exemption Forms Through Maricopa County

Submitting a request for application materials does not itself establish or approve an exemption.

You’ll still need to complete the applicable application, submit required documentation, and satisfy the eligibility requirements.

For additional information, I’ve written a separate article on this important benefit.

Arizona Disabled Veteran Property Tax Exemption: A Major Win for Veterans

Always confirm current application deadlines and requirements with your county assessor.

Can I Remove Escrow From My Mortgage?

Sometimes.

Certain conventional mortgage loans may allow eligible homeowners to waive or remove an escrow account, subject to applicable loan terms, investor requirements, servicing policies, and potentially additional fees or pricing considerations.

Other mortgage programs, including FHA loans, generally require escrow accounts.

But here’s what I want to emphasize.

Removing escrow doesn’t eliminate property taxes or homeowners insurance.

It simply changes who is responsible for making those payments directly.

Instead of contributing monthly through your mortgage payment, you may need to pay large bills yourself when they’re due.

For some homeowners, that works well.

For others, having the expenses collected monthly makes budgeting much easier.

Before requesting an escrow waiver, make sure you understand the requirements and your ability to manage those expenses independently.

Five Things to Do Before Considering a Refinance

If your mortgage payment unexpectedly increases, don’t automatically assume refinancing is the answer.

Start here.

1. Review Your Annual Escrow Analysis

Look at the breakdown of your projected property taxes, insurance premiums, escrow balance, and any shortage repayment.

Determine whether the increase is ongoing, temporary, or both.

2. Review Your Homeowners Insurance

Contact your insurance professional and ask whether your current coverage and premium are appropriate.

Compare available options, but don’t sacrifice important protection just to lower your payment.

3. Check Your Property Tax Assessment

Review your county assessor’s property information.

Make sure the details are accurate and investigate any exemptions or appeal options for which you may qualify.

4. Ask Your Mortgage Servicer About Escrow Options

If you have a shortage, ask how the repayment is being handled.

Find out whether a voluntary lump-sum payment is permitted and how it would affect future monthly collections.

5. Understand the Cause Before Replacing Your Mortgage

If your payment increased because of taxes or insurance, refinancing generally won’t eliminate those expenses.

And if you currently have a particularly attractive fixed interest rate, replacing that mortgage could increase your principal and interest payment.

There may be legitimate reasons to consider refinancing, including debt consolidation, accessing equity, or changing loan terms.

But an escrow shortage alone isn’t necessarily one of them.

Sometimes the smartest mortgage decision is keeping the mortgage you already have.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my mortgage payment increase even with a fixed interest rate?

Yes. Your scheduled principal and interest payment generally stays the same on a traditional fixed-rate mortgage, but property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, and escrow adjustments can change your total monthly payment.

Why did my mortgage payment increase by $200 or $300?

Common reasons include higher property taxes, increased homeowners insurance premiums, and an escrow shortage. Your annual escrow analysis should help explain the specific changes.

Will my mortgage payment go back down after an escrow shortage?

It might. If part of your increase is a temporary shortage repayment, that portion may end once the shortage is resolved. However, higher ongoing taxes and insurance costs may remain.

Can I pay my escrow shortage in one lump sum?

Your servicer may accept a voluntary lump-sum payment, depending on the shortage and applicable servicing requirements. Paying the shortage doesn’t eliminate higher future tax or insurance expenses.

If I receive a homeowners insurance refund, should I put it into escrow?

First, contact your mortgage servicer. Determine how the replacement insurance premium was paid and whether the refund is needed to cover an existing or future escrow shortfall.

Why are property taxes sometimes low on a newly constructed home?

The available tax history may not fully reflect the completed home. As the county updates its valuation records, property taxes may change, potentially increasing the amount collected through escrow.

Can a disabled veteran receive a property tax exemption in Arizona?

Certain qualifying veterans with disabilities may be eligible for partial or full property tax exemptions, subject to current Arizona law and individual eligibility requirements. Contact your county assessor for details.

Should I refinance if my mortgage payment increases?

Not automatically. First determine why the payment changed. If the increase is caused by property taxes or insurance, refinancing generally won’t remove those expenses.

The Bottom Line: Your Mortgage Rate May Be Fixed. Your Cost of Homeownership Isn’t.

Here’s what I want homeowners to remember.

A fixed-rate mortgage can provide stability.

Your interest rate stays the same, and on a traditional fully amortizing fixed-rate loan, your scheduled principal and interest payment remains consistent.

But owning a home involves expenses beyond principal and interest.

Property taxes change.

Insurance premiums change.

Escrow shortages happen.

And sometimes there are opportunities to reduce expenses through insurance reviews or property tax exemptions.

Whether you’re purchasing your first home, changing insurance companies, or reviewing an unexpected mortgage payment increase, don’t just look at what your payment is today.

Understand what could make it change tomorrow.

If you’re unsure why your mortgage payment increased, I’m happy to help you understand the mortgage side of the equation and identify the right questions to ask your servicer.

Before you refinance, let’s understand the problem.

Mortgage Guidance. Not Mortgage Pressure.

Doug Caldwell
Executive Loan Officer | Rocket Mortgage, LLC
NMLS #1697500
925-421-7280
www.dougisyourlender.com


Important Disclosure: This article is intended for general educational purposes only. Mortgage servicing rules, escrow requirements, property tax assessments, insurance premiums, exemption eligibility, and lender policies may change. Examples are hypothetical and do not represent actual loan terms or tax assessments. Individual circumstances vary. Always consult your mortgage servicer, county assessor, insurance professional, or mortgage lender for current information applicable to your situation. Rocket Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #3030. Equal Housing Lender.